KETJU Research

← The Register

Liquidity pool

Curve DEX

Not approved Liquidity pools are outside the approved structures
Issued
2026-08-15
Last confirmed
2026-08-15
Next check due
2026-11-15
Chains
Ethereum · No freeze key, Arbitrum One · Mixed control, Monad · Governed, no freeze, Polygon PoS · Mixed control, Base · Mixed control, Avalanche · Governed, no freeze, Plasma · Issuer can freeze, Gnosis Chain · Governed, no freeze, OP Mainnet · Mixed control

Curve is a decentralized exchange built around stableswap pools that make trades between like-priced assets cheap. It held about $1.4B across thirteen chains at the 2026-08-14 survey. Its StableSwap formula concentrates liquidity near parity, but an LP still sells the asset holding its peg and accumulates the one breaking it. The July 2023 Vyper reentrancy exploit also shows that audited, mature infrastructure can suffer losses in specific pools, though that incident is not the reason for this verdict. The AMM class rule decides this case, not an individual review and rejection. Unavoidable inventory rebalancing and exposure to impermanent loss rule it out for the advised sleeve.

The research file

The mechanism

Curve’s StableSwap formula blends constant-sum behavior near a target price with constant-product behavior farther away. This produces low slippage for correlated assets, but LP tokens remain pro-rata claims on pool inventory. As relative prices move, arbitrageurs trade against the pool and leave LPs with more of the depreciating asset. Metapools and yield-bearing underlying tokens can add dependencies beyond the base pool.

Control and operating record

Curve includes both core deployments and permissionless factory pools. The code, assets, oracles and admin controls therefore differ by pool. veCRV governance can change parameters and direct gauges, but it cannot restore an external asset’s peg. On 30 July 2023, attackers used reentrancy against pools compiled with vulnerable Vyper versions. Curve governance later approved 71.77 million CRV of vesting compensation for affected LPs. That response is useful evidence about operations, not proof that all pool code or assets have the same risk profile.

The exit

LPs can remove liquidity in the supported coin mix, subject to pool balances, fees and transaction execution. During a depeg, the quoted LP-token value can hide a harmful inventory mix. An exit in one coin can realize large slippage, while a balanced exit returns the impaired asset itself. Calling the loss impermanent does not make par recovery available on demand.

Why the class rule decides

The amm-lp rule excludes recommendations whose core return requires continuous two-sided market making. Curve’s efficient math, long operating history and response to losses do not change that payoff for the client. This is not an individual finding that Curve is unsafe. A Curve product with no AMM inventory exposure would require a separate memo and could reopen review.

Class rule

The amm lp class is outside the approved structures, so every protocol in it is not approved until the rule changes. The rule is about the structure, not an adverse finding about this protocol, and it is not a client instruction. The events that would reopen it are listed with the memo.

Sources

The claims above trace to these. Where a number could not be independently verified, the thesis says so.

Inherited controls

The research above describes the protocol layer. Every position also inherits the asset it holds and the chain it settles on. The layer with the most administrative power sets the position’s effective control; that describes control, not quality or suitability.

ChainVerdictControlControl constraint
EthereumApproved No freeze key No sequencer, no upgrade key, no operator who can be compelled. Rule changes require social consensus.
Arbitrum OneApproved with limits Mixed control a single sequencer orders >99% of transactions and admin keys can upgrade bridge contracts on a ~7-day timelock.
MonadApproved with limits Governed, no freeze the L1 has a public validator path, but its short production record, single initial client lineage, and Foundation-directed delegation keep stake and operations concentrated.
Polygon PoSRejected Mixed control a public validator set orders transactions, but a 5-of-9 multisig can instantly upgrade staking and canonical bridge contracts, while a 5-of-8 controls custom child tokens.
BaseApproved with limits Mixed control Coinbase, one regulated US company, operates the only sequencer, and admin keys can upgrade bridge contracts within ~7 days.
AvalancheApproved with limits Governed, no freeze no party can freeze or seize C-Chain funds, but one vendor writes the only production client and Messari measured over a third of stake hosted on AWS.
PlasmaRejected Issuer can freeze the production validator committee is permissioned and the public docs still describe decentralization as a phased future rollout with no fixed access timeline.
Gnosis ChainApproved with limits Governed, no freeze the chain validator path is permissionless, but its xDAI and canonical bridge exposure adds an 8-of-15 governor multisig outside the base consensus grade.
OP MainnetRejected Mixed control Ethereum forced inclusion limits sequencer censorship, but the Foundation and Security Council can co-sign an immediate upgrade before a client can exit.
The memo is public. Monitoring connects the research to positions clients actually hold and flags evidence changes for advisor review. $49 per advisor per month, first 14 days free. Start the trial.